It is an increasingly common worry: an elderly relative, perhaps after a stroke or a dementia diagnosis, makes a new will that changes everything – leaving the estate solely to one child, or to a new acquaintance, and cutting others out. Can the will be challenged, and if so, when and where? A recent High Court decision is a useful reminder of the answer. A finding by one court about a person’s mental state does not automatically decide the fate of their will, particularly where some of the people involved were not part of the earlier proceedings.
Capacity, wills and two different courts
Two separate courts can become involved when capacity and wills are in issue, and they perform distinct roles. The Court of Protection (CoP) exists to protect those who may lack the mental ‘capacity’ to make decisions for themselves. In this role, it can decide whether a person has capacity now, appoint deputies, and even, in some cases, make a "statutory will" on behalf of someone who can no longer make rational decisions. However, what it does not do is rule on whether a will that a person made for themselves is valid.
This question is for the probate court and, crucially, it can generally only be decided after the person has died. A will has no effect while its maker is alive. It can be revoked or replaced at any time, provided the person making it (the testator) still has the capacity to do so. For that reason, you cannot usually go to court to have a living person’s will declared invalid in advance, however suspicious the circumstances may look. After death, in a probate claim, the court can examine whether the will was properly signed and witnessed, whether the person had the mental capacity to make it, whether they knew and approved of what it said, and whether they were free from pressure or fraud.
A disputed late will
In a recent case, a testator made a will in 2001 leaving his estate to his wife or, if she died before him, to his three children equally. After suffering a stroke some years later, while living with one of his daughters, he made a new will leaving everything to her, while his other two children sought to have the earlier will upheld.
While the testator was still alive, the CoP looked closely at his capacity. In 2023, it was decided that he had lacked capacity to make lasting powers of attorney as of July 2021. The CoP also went on to declare the 2021 will invalid, even though it had no power to do so.
After the testator died in 2024, his daughter brought a probate claim to prove the 2021 will. Her siblings, acting as executors of their late mother’s estate, asked the court to stop the claim before trial, arguing that the CoP had already settled the matter. The court refused on two grounds. The first was that the mother’s estate was not part of the earlier case, and a court’s findings in one case do not generally bind those who were not involved in it. The CoP’s findings therefore did not bind the mother’s estate and could not simply be used as evidence in the probate claim. Further, the CoP has no power to decide whether a will is valid or otherwise, and its role is simply to protect those who may lack capacity during their lifetime. Whether a will is actually valid is for the probate court to decide once the testator has died.
This decision doesn’t mean the later will has necessarily been upheld, only that the claim could go ahead. The claimant has won the right to argue her case, but she may find it hard to succeed, given the noted incapacity.
Implications:
The first is about timing. If you are worried that a relative has made a will in suspicious circumstances, you generally cannot challenge it while they are alive. If your concern is that they may currently lack capacity to make decisions, the CoP may be able to help. However, as this case illustrates, it cannot rule on the will itself, and the practical response is to gather and preserve evidence, such as medical records and the solicitor’s notes, so that the position can be tested later, if necessary.
However, access to those records during someone’s lifetime may require their consent and any necessary legal authority, so it is best to seek advice. After death, time limits apply to challenging a will and to related claims, so act promptly.
The second is that one court’s findings do not automatically carry across to another. Findings about capacity made in the CoP do not necessarily bind a later probate dispute, particularly where some of the people involved were not part of the earlier case. The Probate Court will decide the question on its own evidence although, in practice, detailed findings may still be a strong guide to what the evidence ultimately shows.
The third is for anyone making a will later in life, or helping a relative to do so. The best protection against a later dispute is clear evidence, created at the time, that the person understood what they were doing. That means using a solicitor who assesses and records capacity. Where capacity might be questioned later, it is also good practice to have a doctor assess the person at the time. Evidence prepared in advance is worth far more than argument after the event.
To recap:
- A living person’s will can’t be challenged for validity. Disputes about it are decided after death.
- Worries about someone’s current capacity can go to the CoP, but it cannot rule on their will.
- Findings from one court don’t automatically bind people who weren’t part of that case.
- Winning the right to bring a claim is not the same as winning it. The merits are decided separately.
- If you’re concerned, keep records now and take advice early, because time limits apply after death.
- If you’re making a will later in life, get a solicitor involved and, where capacity might be questioned, a doctor’s assessment at the time.
Disclaimer: This simplified summary of a UK legal case is intended for general information only. It is based on a claim issued in the High Court. It is not intended as legal advice, may omit important detail, and may not reflect any subsequent developments or appeals. Please read the full judgement and seek professional legal advice before acting.