Protection for those persecuted for their sexuality

The UK has long offered refuge to those who face persecution in their home country for who they are, and that can include their sexual orientation. A recent tribunal decision illustrates how that protection works and highlights an important principle – that no one should be expected to hide a fundamental part of themselves to stay safe.

Who qualifies as a refugee?

Under the Refugee Convention of 1951, a refugee is defined as someone who has a well-founded fear of persecution in their home country as a consequence of their race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership of a "particular social group". The courts have long recognised that people who are persecuted because of their sexual orientation fall into the latter category.

Those who face a real risk of serious harm in their own country because they are gay, lesbian or bisexual may be entitled to seek refugee protection in the UK. Two further conditions matter – that the protection is for those whose own state cannot, or will not, protect them, and who cannot reasonably be expected to move to a safer part of their own country.

The principle you should not have to hide

A question that once troubled these cases was whether a claimant could simply avoid persecution by being discreet and by keeping their sexuality hidden. The Supreme Court originally settled this point in the case HJ (Iran) in 2010. It determined that a person cannot be refused asylum on the basis that they could conceal their sexual orientation to avoid harm. If they were to live openly and would face persecution as a consequence, then they qualify. If they would hide it, then the tribunal asks why and, if a material reason for hiding it is the fear of persecution, they still qualify, as the law does not require anyone to suppress a core part of their identity to remain safe.

The recent case applied exactly that approach. The claimant, a Nigerian man, asserted that he was bisexual and feared persecution at home. The Tribunal accepted his account, finding that he would not conceal his sexuality and should not be expected to do so, and concluded that he qualified for protection, given that bisexual men in Nigeria constitute a recognised social group, and that the Home Office accepted that neither state protection nor relocation was realistic.

Implications:

Credibility is central in such a case, and a tribunal will assess it holistically. It weighs the person's own account against the documentary evidence provided and any background evidence about conditions in their country. Importantly, rejecting one part of an account does not mean rejecting all of it: here the Judge gave little weight to one unreliable document, yet still accepted the core of the claim because it was consistent and fitted the wider evidence. However, any delay in claiming asylum can count against a claimant, though it is not automatically decisive; here, it carried limited weight because the claimant had not realised the claim could be based on sexual orientation.

As the appellant claimed asylum in January 2025, the Tribunal applied the two-stage test under Section 32 of the Nationality and Borders Act 2022, which first requires the claimant to prove his sexuality and subjective fear on the "balance of probabilities" first, before assessing any 'objective risk' of his returning to Nigeria.

The decision also shows a familiar second route running in parallel with the asylum claim, with the Tribunal explicitly allowing the appeal on both asylum grounds and human rights grounds under Article 8 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), and also the UK Human Rights Act 1998 – the right to respect for family life – as the claimant had a young child in the UK and removing him would have been a disproportionate interference with that relationship, with the child's best interests weighing heavily in this instance. It is common for a protection claim and a human rights claim to be advanced concomitantly, each serving as an independent basis for staying. In summary:

  • Claimants qualify for protection if living openly puts them at risk of persecution, or if they only hide their sexuality out of fear.
  • Tribunals evaluate a person's entire story alongside supporting evidence, meaning one unreliable document does not automatically defeat an otherwise consistent claim.
  • Waiting to claim asylum can hurt a claimant's credibility, though it is not automatically fatal if there is a reasonable explanation.
  • Claimants can run a separate human rights claim alongside an asylum application, such as protecting the right to family life when a young child is living in the UK.

The practical lessons from this judgement are consistent, in that they are evidence-heavy, fact-sensitive claims in which consistency and supporting material count for a great deal. For other asylum seekers, it helps to claim promptly where possible and to take early specialist advice, since more than one legal route may be open. Above all, the case reflects a settled principle of refugee law – that protection exists for people who are genuinely at risk because of who they are, and that safety should never be made conditional on hiding it.

Disclaimer:  This simplified summary of a UK legal case is intended for general information only. It is based on a claim addressed by a tribunal. It is not intended as legal advice, may omit important detail, and may not reflect any subsequent developments or appeals. Please read the full judgement and seek professional legal advice before acting.

Source:Equality and Human Rights Commission | 15-11-2026
Scroll to Top